Porsche
Cayman
Porsche
911
Porsche Cayman vs. 911: Performance, Prestige, and Price Compared
When it comes to high-performance sports cars, Porsche offers two icons that ignite serious passion—the mid-engine Cayman and the legendary rear-engine 911. Whether you're a weekend thrill-seeker or a lifelong Porsche enthusiast, choosing between the two isn't easy—but we can help.
In our Porsche Cayman vs. 911 comparison, the Cayman is more affordable, sharper in corners, and ideal for pure driving engagement, while the 911 brings more power, prestige, and daily versatility with its iconic design and broader performance range.
At Hennessy Porsche North Atlanta, we've helped thousands of drivers in Roswell, Atlanta, and Morrow find the right Porsche for their lifestyle. With decades of expertise and hands-on experience, we understand what sets each model apart—and which one suits you best.We'll walk you through a head-to-head look at performance, handling, comfort, and pricing, so you can feel confident in your next move. Let's break down how these two legendary machines truly compare—and which one deserves your spot in the garage.
Summary:
- The Porsche Cayman offers a more affordable, nimble, and driver-focused experience, making it ideal for enthusiasts who prioritize balance and handling over raw power.
- The Porsche 911 delivers unmatched versatility, prestige, and performance range, with more power, passenger room, and luxury features for daily driving or track days.
- Your choice between the Porsche Cayman vs. 911 depends on your driving style, lifestyle needs, and budget—and either way, you're getting pure Porsche engineering at its finest.
A Quick Comparison: Porsche Cayman vs. Porsche 911
- +$47,300 price advantage for the Cayman — experience Porsche performance without the 911 premium.
- +3 mpg city / +2 mpg highway fuel efficiency edge for the Cayman — better mileage for everyday driving.
- -276 lbs curb weight difference makes the Cayman feel lighter, more agile, and sharper in corners.
- +15 cu-ft cargo capacity in the Cayman with dual trunks — more room for gear, groceries, or weekend bags.
- +More neutral weight distribution (45:55 vs. 52:48) gives the Cayman superior balance and predictability in turns.
- +2.0 seconds quicker 0–60 time in the top-tier 911 Turbo S vs. Cayman GTS — unmatched straight-line speed when power matters most.
- Passenger Space: The 911 offers 2+2 seating versus the Cayman's 2-seat layout, making it the more versatile choice if you need occasional back seats. However, the Cayman's cabin is more driver-focused and offers a surprisingly roomy feel for two.
Quick Specs
| Feature | Porsche Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine (Base) | 2.0L Turbocharged Flat-Four | 3.0L Twin-Turbocharged Flat-Six | The 911 offers more horsepower, but the Cayman feels lighter and more responsive at lower speeds. |
| Horsepower / Torque (Base) | 300 hp / 280 lb-ft | 379 hp / 331 lb-ft | The 911 packs more power, especially useful for straight-line performance. |
| 0-60 mph (Base) | 4.6 seconds | 4.0 seconds | 911 is quicker off the line, but Cayman is still very fast for its price. |
| Top Speed (Base) | 170 mph | 182 mph | Both deliver serious speed, but the 911 pushes the limits further. |
| MPG (City/Highway) | 21 / 27 | 18 / 25 | Cayman is more efficient for daily use or commuting. |
| Highest Trim Option | GTS 4.0 - 394 hp / 317 lb-ft | Turbo S - 640 hp / 590 lb-ft | Cayman is about precision; 911 Turbo S is a supercar in disguise. |
| 0-60 mph (Highest Trim) | 3.8 seconds (GTS 4.0) | 2.6 seconds (Turbo S) | The 911 Turbo S is nearly unmatched in acceleration at its price tier. |
Gallery
Porsche
Cayman
Porsche
911
Detailed Feature Breakdown
Performance Specs Showdown: 2025 Cayman vs. 911
| Feature | Porsche Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine Placement | Mid-engine | Rear-engine | Cayman offers balance and predictability; 911 rewards skill. |
| Weight Distribution | 45:55 | 52:48 | Mid-engine Cayman rotates better in corners; 911 excels at high speed. |
| Steering Feel | Sharper, more direct | Smooth, more stable at speed | Cayman excels at low-speed handling; 911 comes alive at higher speeds. |
| Suspension | Adaptive dampers available | Porsche Active Suspension Management (PASM) | PASM in 911 adds a comfort edge for daily use. |
| Rear-Axle Steering | Not available | Available on select trims | Gives 911 better maneuverability despite size. |
| Cornering Style | Pivot-like precision in tight turns | Stability-focused with explosive exits | Cayman is better for twisty roads; 911 shines on fast sweepers. |
| Braking Performance | Available carbon ceramics | Standard high-performance brakes | Cayman brakes are lighter and fade-resistant; both perform excellently. |
In the Porsche Cayman vs 911 performance matchup, the 2025 Cayman thrives on lightness and precision, delivering an agile feel that's hard to beat in real-world driving. Its naturally aspirated flat-six in the GTS 4.0 sings at high revs, giving Roswell-area drivers that visceral thrill without relying on brute force.
The 911 lineup is broader, faster, and more tech-loaded, ranging from grand touring smoothness to track-killer GT3 specs. But in terms of accessible excitement per dollar, the Cayman makes a strong case as the best sports car for Georgia backroads and city commutes alike.
Porsche Cayman vs 911 Handling: Balance vs. Brute Grip
| Feature | Porsche Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine Placement | Mid-engine | Rear-engine | Cayman offers balance and predictability; 911 rewards skill. |
| Weight Distribution | 45:55 | 52:48 | Mid-engine Cayman rotates better in corners; 911 excels at high speed. |
| Steering Feel | Sharper, more direct | Smooth, more stable at speed | Cayman excels at low-speed handling; 911 comes alive at higher speeds. |
| Suspension | Adaptive dampers available | Porsche Active Suspension Management (PASM) | PASM in 911 adds a comfort edge for daily use. |
| Rear-Axle Steering | Not available | Available on select trims | Gives 911 better maneuverability despite size. |
| Cornering Style | Pivot-like precision in tight turns | Stability-focused with explosive exits | Cayman is better for twisty roads; 911 shines on fast sweepers. |
| Braking Performance | Available carbon ceramics | Standard high-performance brakes | Cayman brakes are lighter and fade-resistant; both perform excellently. |
When it comes to Porsche Cayman vs 911 handling, the Cayman’s mid-engine layout gives it the edge in balance, especially in tight curves or mountain runs near North Georgia. It feels like it pivots beneath you, delivering confidence even to newer performance drivers.
Meanwhile, the 911’s rear-engine design brings explosive traction and high-speed stability, favored by those who like to push hard on track days or weekend blasts down I-75. Both cars are engaging, but the Cayman vs 911 comparison shows two very different takes on corner-carving precision.
Interior Feel and Function: Porsche Cayman vs 911 Interior
| Feature | Porsche Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seating Configuration | 2 seats | 2+2 (rear seats best for small passengers) | Cayman prioritizes driver engagement; 911 offers extra versatility. |
| Cargo Space | 15.0 cu-ft (dual trunks) | 4.8 cu-ft | Cayman has more usable storage for road trips. |
| Digital Cockpit | 10.9" touchscreen + digital cluster | Full digital display + HUD on higher trims | 911 cockpit is more tech-loaded, but both are modern and clean. |
| Premium Audio Options | Available | Standard Bose surround sound | 911 comes more feature-packed out of the box. |
| Seat Options | Sport seats, carbon buckets on GT4 RS | Adaptive sport seats with massage options | 911 leans more toward luxury; Cayman leans toward sport. |
| Daily Comfort | Surprisingly refined for a sports car | Smoother ride, more refined cabin | Cayman's interior is great, but the 911 feels more upscale overall. |
The Porsche Cayman vs 911 interior matchup is more than just leather and stitching—it's about focus. The Cayman keeps it minimal and driver-centric, with just enough tech to support the experience without distracting from it. You sit lower, more connected, and more in control.
The 911, on the other hand, offers a more luxurious layout, with expanded features and rear seats that are small but useful in a pinch. If you’re after a more refined daily driver or a road trip-worthy luxury sedan alternative, the 911 makes a stronger case—but the Porsche 718 Cayman vs 911 choice here comes down to how much comfort you want with your speed.
Pricing and Value: Which Porsche Delivers More?
| Feature | Porsche Cayman | Porsche 911 | Dealership Notes |
| Starting MSRP (Base) | $72,800 | $120,100 | Cayman offers serious Porsche performance at a far lower entry point. |
| Top-End MSRP | ~$100,000 (GTS 4.0) | Over $400,000 (GT3 RS) | The 911's model range stretches from sports car to full-on supercar. |
| Cost of Ownership | Lower maintenance, better MPG | Higher insurance, higher upkeep costs | Cayman is more affordable to run long term. |
| Resale Value (5 years) | ~50-55% retained | ~60-70% retained | 911s are investment-grade icons with incredible resale value. |
| Warranty | 4yr / 50,000 mi | 4yr / 50,000 mi | Identical coverage across both lines. |
| Value Proposition | Best Porsche value, lower barrier to entry | Prestige, power, and versatility at a cost | Cayman = pure performance per dollar; 911 = the full Porsche legacy. |
*see dealer for specific details
Looking at Cayman vs 911 specs and pricing, the 718 Cayman offers a significant value advantage, especially in entry and mid-level trims. You're getting authentic Porsche engineering, a flat-six option, and thrilling performance starting well under $80K. The 911 commands a premium for its legacy, higher power ceiling, and versatility, with models like the GTS and Turbo S showcasing Porsche's most advanced tech. Still, in terms of pure dollar-for-thrill ratio, especially for buyers in Atlanta or Buford exploring their first sports car, the Cayman remains the smarter play.
The Verdict: Who Wins the Porsche Cayman vs 911 Battle?
The Porsche Cayman vs. 911 reviews consistently highlight a clear divide: Cayman wins for balance, value, and driver focus, while the 911 dominates with prestige, speed, and everyday usability. If you want a focused weekend weapon or your first true sports car, the Cayman is hard to top.
But if you're chasing legacy, long-haul comfort, or simply want the full-blooded Porsche experience without compromise, the 911 delivers in spades. There's no wrong answer—just two roads to performance perfection in this Cayman vs 911 comparison.
How Can We Help?
* Indicates a required field
FAQs: Porsche Cayman vs. 911 Questions
Still wondering which Porsche fits your lifestyle best? We've gathered the most common questions drivers from Roswell, Atlanta, Buford, and beyond ask when comparing the Porsche Cayman vs. 911 —and we're giving you the straight answers right here.
Which is faster, the Porsche Cayman or the 911?
The 911 is faster in almost every trim, with a quicker 0–60 time and higher top speed. That said, the Cayman still delivers thrilling performance, especially in GTS 4.0 form, and feels lighter and more agile in daily Georgia driving.
Is the Porsche Cayman a good everyday car?
Yes—the Cayman works great as a daily driver in Roswell or Atlanta traffic. It's compact, efficient, and surprisingly practical with front and rear trunks. The ride is firm but comfortable enough for commutes and errands.
Is the 911 worth the higher price tag?
If you're looking for prestige, more power, and added comfort, the 911 earns its premium. It's a more versatile choice for drivers who want a luxury sedan alternative that performs on both highways and track days.
Which Porsche handles better on mountain roads in Georgia?
The Cayman's mid-engine setup offers sharper, more predictable handling, especially on twisty roads. It's the ideal Porsche for carving up the North Georgia mountain routes with confidence and control.
Can the Cayman or 911 fit a family?
The 911 includes small rear seats, which can fit kids or light luggage in a pinch. The Cayman is strictly a two-seater, so it's more suited for solo drivers or couples without the need for back seats.
Which Porsche offers the better value for new buyers?
The Porsche Cayman offers exceptional value with a lower entry price and lower running costs. It's a perfect starting point for drivers in Buford or Morrow looking to join the Porsche family without the full 911 premium.
Where can I compare the Cayman vs. 911 near Roswell, GA?
You can explore both models in person at Hennessy Porsche North Atlanta, conveniently located at 990 Mansell Road, Roswell, GA. We'll help you test drive and compare the Porsche Cayman vs. 911 side-by-side to see which one suits you best.
A Final Word on the Porsche Cayman vs. 911 Match-Up
Whether you're carving corners through North Georgia's winding roads or looking for a showstopping ride for your daily Atlanta commute, both the Cayman and 911 offer distinct advantages. The Cayman rewards precision and driver connection with every turn, while the Porsche 911 blends raw power and daily comfort like no other. Still unsure? The best way to decide isn't on paper—it's behind the wheel.
At Hennessy Porsche North Atlanta, we specialize in helping Georgia drivers find the perfect Porsche for their lifestyle. Our team is passionate, knowledgeable, and ready to guide you through a hands-on comparison of the Porsche 718 Cayman vs 911 lineup—no pressure, just pure performance.
Stop by today for a test drive and discover which Porsche delivers your perfect balance of excitement and everyday excellence. You'll find us at 990 Mansell Road, Roswell, GA 30076, or give us a call at (888) 801-6524 to schedule your visit. Let's get you into the driver's seat of something unforgettable.